Skip to main content

Believe that journalism can make a difference

If you believe in the work we do at Vox, please support us this Giving Tuesday. Our mission has never been more urgent. But our work isn’t easy. It requires resources, dedication, and independence. And that’s where you come in.

We rely on readers like you to fund our journalism. Will you support our work and become a Vox Member today?

Support Vox

Kellyanne Conway made up a fake terrorist attack to justify Trump’s “Muslim ban”

Zack Beauchamp
Zack Beauchamp is a senior correspondent at Vox, where he covers ideology and challenges to democracy, both at home and abroad. His book on democracy, The Reactionary Spirit, was published 0n July 16. You can purchase it here.

In an interview with MSNBC’s Chris Matthews that aired on Thursday night, Trump adviser Kellyanne Conway managed to get two huge things wrong in a short, 19-second answer. First, she said that the Obama administration banned Iraqi refugees from entering in the United States for six months in 2011 — which is flatly untrue.

Second, and more significantly, she made up a terrorist attack committed by Iraqi refugees that never happened — the “Bowling Green Massacre”:

Joe Sonka is, to be clear, 100 percent correct about this. There has never been a terrorist attack in Bowling Green, Kentucky, committed by Iraqi refugees.

Conway claims that “most people don’t know that because it didn’t get covered.” Most people don’t know about it because it didn’t happen.

Where Conway is coming from (I think)

In 2011, two Iraqi refugees, Waad Ramadan Alwan and Mohanad Shareef Hammadi, were arrested in Bowling Green, Kentucky, on federal terrorism charges. Allegedly, they had been plotting to send money and weapons back home to Iraqi insurgents.

During the investigation, the FBI found something worrying: fingerprints from Alwan on a roadside bomb in Iraq. This suggested there was a very specific flaw in America’s refugee screening process: Databases of fingerprints from Iraqi militants were not well-integrated into the broader State Department–run refugee admissions process. As a result, the Obama administration initiated a new review of all roughly 57,000 Iraqi refugees who had been recently admitted into the United States.

This process was manpower- and time-intensive, and resulted in a significant slowdown in Iraqi refugee admissions to the United States for six months. But it was not a ban, as Conway, Trump, and many in the conservative media claimed: Refugees from Iraq entered the United States in all six months.

So, to recap:

  1. No one was killed by refugees in Bowling Green.
  2. There was never even a plan to kill anyone in Bowling Green.
  3. There was no ban on Iraqi refugee admissions afterward.

It is, I suppose, possible that Conway was referring to the other Bowling Green Massacre, which is a local haunted house.

Update: Conway appears to have acknowledged her error, obliquely calling the Bowling Green Massacre an “honest mistake.” But it’s so couched in defensiveness and attacks on the media that it’s hard to tell, so she doesn’t really get any credit given the scale of the mistake:


How should the media cover a White House that isn’t afraid to lie?

A hopeful post-apocalyptic novel for right nowA hopeful post-apocalyptic novel for right now
Audio
The HighlightMember Exclusive

Author Eman Abdelhadi on imagining a better world.

By Jorge Just
He thought he would die in Putin’s gulag. Now he has a message for the world.He thought he would die in Putin’s gulag. Now he has a message for the world.
World Politics

Leading Russian dissident Vladimir Kara-Murza tells Vox the world needs to start preparing now for Putin’s fall.

By Joshua Keating
Trump’s win is part of a mysterious — and ominous — worldwide trendTrump’s win is part of a mysterious — and ominous — worldwide trend
PoliticsMember Exclusive

Why are people all over the world angry at “the system”?

By Zack Beauchamp
Israel and Hezbollah seem headed for a ceasefire. Here’s what we know.Israel and Hezbollah seem headed for a ceasefire. Here’s what we know.
World Politics

What’s in the ceasefire deal, and what could come next.

By Ellen Ioanes
Trump’s tariff plan is an inflation planTrump’s tariff plan is an inflation plan
Trump 2.0, explainedMember Exclusive

New tariffs on Mexico, Canada, and China could make life more expensive.

By Ellen Ioanes
The unexpected place that could become an immigration flashpoint under TrumpThe unexpected place that could become an immigration flashpoint under Trump
Trump 2.0, explained

Trump’s immigration crackdown could extend to the US-Canada border.

By Nicole Narea