clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Not paying NCAA athletes “is the organized theft of black wealth”

The case for paying college athletes, in podcast form.

The Arizona Wildcats and USC Trojans play in the 2018 March Madness tournament.
Parker Jackson Cartwright of the Arizona Wildcats faces off against Jonah Mathews of the USC Trojans.
Ethan Miller/Getty Images

Every year during March Madness, NCAA basketball fans participate in the ritual conversation about whether college athletes should be paid for their labor. At present, many students are offered scholarships but not paid beyond that scholarship, nor do they have the time to hold on-campus employment. The schools, meanwhile, make millions.

This year, something is different: An investigative report from Yahoo revealed an underground economy of payments and favors between universities and potential athletes and their families. And while the NCAA was quick to cry foul and penalize offending parties, the report has reignited the debate around what athletes should have been entitled to all along. Complicating the debate: Black students make up more than half of Division 1 basketball players, and the policy that they shouldn’t be paid is supported by mostly white people.

Furthermore, because many of these students come from precarious financial situations at home, they don’t have the luxury of boycotting or going on strike. They have to watch as the NCAA makes billions from their performance — in ticket sales, merchandise, and more — while they (if they’re following the NCAA-dictated rules) never see a cent.

Dave Zirin, sports editor at The Nation, makes his case in the latest episode of Today, Explained:

“[College athletes] are workers, and their labor funds a huge portion of the modern university. They exist as a way, in the current collegiate landscape, to produce revenue and produce money that otherwise would not exist.”

Listen to Zirin’s full argument on the latest episode of Today, Explained alongside former NCAA star Ed O’Bannon.

Related reading:

How do I get even more Today, Explained?

You can get the news we’re reading throughout the day, facts and stats to make you smarter about the world, and behind-the-scenes photos on Twitter at @Today_Explained. You can follow Sean at @Rameswaram, Dave Zirin at @EdgeOfSports, and Ed O’Bannon at @Ed_Obannon.

How do I report a problem?

For all issues or feedback, please email

How do I listen?

If you don’t see the player above, you can listen, subscribe, and review Today, Explained on Stitcher, Apple Podcasts, and Google Play Music.

What if I want to listen at home?

If you have Amazon Echo, add Today, Explained to your flash briefing. If you have Google Home, just say, “Hey Google, play the Today, Explained podcast!”

Sign up for the newsletter Today, Explained

Understand the world with a daily explainer plus the most compelling stories of the day.