clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Trump says he won’t commit to leaving office if he loses the election because of a “ballot scam”

He politicized an incident in Pennsylvania to make an unfounded claim that Democrats are “cheating” in the election.

US President Donald Trump waves as he concludes his remarks during a campaign rally on September 25, 2020 in Newport News, Virginia.
Drew Angerer/Getty Images

President Donald Trump’s reelection campaign is looking less like a run for office and more like an operation to justify disputing the election result in the event Trump loses in November.

At a rally in Newport News, Virginia, on Friday night, Trump again refused to say whether he would peacefully transition out of the White House if he loses the presidential election this November, suggesting he would only do so if he was convinced Democrats and their presidential nominee, Joe Biden, did not cheat.

“We’ve gotta watch this ballot scam, because they’re scamming us. And then they say, ‘He doesn’t want to turn over [power].’ Of course I do. But it’s gotta be a fair election,” Trump told the rally crowd.

This scam — which does not exist — became apparent, Trump told his audience, “when they’re losing ballots all over the place, when they’re losing ballots that just happen to be Trump ballots.”

This was an apparent reference to an incident earlier this week in which nine mail-in ballots were found discarded in the trash in Luzerne County, Pennsylvania, at least seven of which were cast for the president. While the Justice Department and FBI have opened investigations into the incident, there’s no initial evidence of malfeasance, either locally or nationally. This has created the appearance of a politically motivated investigation, as Vox’s Andrew Prokop explained:

If there are reports of issues with ballots, the Justice Department should naturally investigate. But the way this information was dribbled out seemed designed to bolster President Trump’s baseless claims that mail voting is deeply flawed — when [US attorney for the Middle District of Pennsylvania David] Freed’s actual findings have so far revealed no such thing.

The first public indications that something was up came when Trump himself told a Fox host in a radio interview that “Trump ballots” in “a trash can” were found in “a certain state,” and when White House press secretary Kayleigh McEnany mentioned at a press briefing that “ballots for the president were found in Pennsylvania.”

Then Freed released his first statement on the matter. The brief, vague statement said he could confirm that “a small number of military ballots” — nine — were “discarded.” It didn’t explain how or why, or whether there was intentional malfeasance. But the statement made sure to point out that “all nine ballots were cast for presidential candidate Donald Trump.” (This statement turned out to be wrong. Freed corrected it to say that seven of the nine were cast for Trump, the other two were resealed and their candidate preference is unknown.)

Local county election officials have blamed the discarded ballots on a seasonal temporary contractor who was dismissed over the incident.

Nevertheless, Trump tried to use the incident to bolster his claim that the election is rigged against him, potentially setting the stage for a legal dispute over the eventual result.

“We’re not going to lose this, except if they cheat. That’s the way I look at it,” Trump said. “We can’t let them cheat because our country at stake. These people will destroy our country [and] we can’t let this happen. ... The Democrats know better than all of us what’s going to happen.”

Trump has intensified existing concerns he won’t leave office if he loses in November

The president’s remarks Friday took comments he made on a transition of power at a Thursday press conference a step further. “Win, lose, or draw in this election, will you commit here today for a peaceful transferral of power after the election?” Trump was asked during a press conference by Brian Karem, the White House reporter for Playboy.

“We’re gonna have to see what happens,” Trump said in response. “We want to get rid of the ballots, and we’ll have a very peaceful — there won’t be a transfer, frankly. There’ll be a continuation.”

Friday, the president made clear what he will be waiting to see, saying, “We do want a very friendly transition. But we don’t want to be cheated, and be stupid, and say, ‘Oh, let’s transiti —’ Well, we’ll go and we’ll do a transition, and we know that there were thousands and thousands of ballots that made the difference through cheating. We’re not going to stand for it.”

For some time, the president has been unwilling to commit to leaving office as presidents have for centuries. And his authoritarian refusals to cooperate with the democratic process have long been a pattern of his presidency.

In July, the president also refused to commit to a peaceful transfer of power in a Fox News interview with Chris Wallace.

On Twitter, and in speeches, the president has highlighted memes about running for office every four years for the next several decades. He has also said he deserves extra time in office beyond the constitutionally allowed eight years due to the investigations he faced. The president has written such statements off as “jokes,” but they take on a more serious tenor when taken alongside his remarks on transferring power, seeming more like a genuine threat to American democracy.

Trump’s antics were followed Saturday by his nomination of federal Judge Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court, to fill the seat of the late Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg.

Barrett is his third Supreme Court nomination in three years, and he has suggested he believes the new justice will ensure the court issues rulings favorable to him should it take up any election-related lawsuits.

All this becomes more concerning given national polls have consistently showed him to be running behind Biden. If the president is to lose the election — particularly if the loss is by a narrow margin — it appears he may be willing to grasp at any straw to justify calling the loss into question.

Sign up for the newsletter Today, Explained

Understand the world with a daily explainer plus the most compelling stories of the day.