clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

A conservative reveals what’s really going on with denying Kavanuagh accusations

It’s all about abortion.

brett kavanaugh, christine ford, sexual assault
Trump Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh at hearing.
Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
Zack Beauchamp is a senior correspondent at Vox, where he covers ideology and challenges to democracy, both at home and abroad. Before coming to Vox in 2014, he edited TP Ideas, a section of Think Progress devoted to the ideas shaping our political world.

Since Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh’s accuser Christine Blasey Ford went public on Sunday, many of Kavanaugh’s conservative supporters have steadfastly refused to deem her sexual assault allegation credible. The most common response has been unconditional denial that Kavanaugh assaulted Ford — the line taken by the White House and the nominee himself.

Others have questioned whether, even if the allegations are true, they are a sufficient reason to block Kavanaugh’s confirmation. Stephen L. Miller, who writes opinion pieces for Fox News and the New York Post, described the sequence of events — Ford claims Kavanaugh dragged her into a room, held her down, groped her, and turned up music to muffle her cries — as “drunk teenagers playing seven minutes in heaven.

To understand this aggressive response, you need only read a single short blog post. The piece, written by prominent conservative pundit Erick Erickson on his site the Resurgent, shows a picture of a fetus accompanied by the following short text (I’ve omitted nothing):

The glee you are seeing from the left and a lot of left leaning “reporters” pushing the “credibly accused” line stems from a world view that can look at the picture above and see a clump of cells worth ripping apart in the name of convenience.

The left is perfectly willing to destroy a man’s reputation in order to keep destroying children. They will use a 35 year old uncorroborated, single sourced, 35 year old claim of a woman who first made the accusation in 2012 after Kavanaugh’s name had circulated in the press as a possible Supreme Court pick for Romney in order to protect the right to kill girls in utero.

Just remember that. This entire thing is about the right to kill kids, not about the veracity of the accusation.

Erickson is insisting that this is about something he views as bigger than sexual assault and #MeToo. He sees a desperate power play aimed at preserving Roe v. Wade: Not only should Ford not be believed, but she must have political motivations because the stakes are so very high.

By casting a debate about sexual assault as a debate about abortion, Erickson reveals that he is the one seeing through the lens of abortion politics — along with much of the organized conservative movement.

Now, it’s the certainly the case that liberals are concerned about Roe’s fate. But sexual assault, and holding powerful men accountable for their actions, has become one of the top issues for the liberal movement in the #MeToo era — and the idea that we should believe accusers is one of the movement’s guiding principles. A Democratic senator, Al Franken, was forced to resign under pressure from his own colleagues after facing accusations of groping women. There’s just no evidence that the broader left doesn’t really care about the kind of allegations Kavanaugh is facing.

Erickson’s argument is classic projection. He sees the stakes as being the future of Roe, and appears to have formulated his views on the credibility of Ford’s allegations accordingly. He assumes his opponents have done the same, even though that’s not at all clear. In doing so, Erickson is revealing why the conservative reaction to the Kavanaugh allegations has been so volcanic — in unusually honest terms.

Despite the rhetoric of the Kavanaugh debate — in which conservatives downplayed the nominee’s commitment to overturning Roe v. Wade in order to court moderate senators — it’s obvious that Kavanaugh would likely be the decisive fifth vote to overturn abortion rights in America. Getting Kavanaugh on the court is the culmination of a decades-long project to overturn Roe v. Wade and push the country to the right. Many of the people committed to this project are not going to let an allegation of sexual assault — even a credible one — get in the way.

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for Vox Recommends

Get curated picks of the best Vox journalism to read, watch, and listen to every week, from our editors.