clock menu more-arrow no yes

Trump claims the US lost $817 billion on trade last year. That’s wrong.

Trump either doesn’t know how trade deficits work or he’s lying.

President Trump Meets With President of the European Commission
President Donald Trump meets with President of the European Commission Jean-Claude Juncker, in the Oval Office at the White House on July 25, 2018.
Kevin Dietsch-Pool/Getty Images

President Donald Trump can’t keep his numbers straight on trade.

On Wednesday, Trump decried “weak” politicians calling for him to stop imposing tariffs on US trade allies — and repeated a lie to make his case: The US “lost $817 billion on trade last year,” he tweeted.

This isn’t true — and it’s not at all clear where Trump is getting this $817 billion number. The White House did not respond to a request for clarification.

Here’s the closest we could get to Trump’s “$817 billion” trade deficit: If you only look at the trade imbalance for the exchange of goods — tangible products like steel or soybeans — the United States bought $811 billion more than it sold in 2017, according to the United States Census Bureau’s annual report.

But economists will point out that even declaring an $811 billion trade deficit is misleading. Trade deficits are calculated based on goods and services — an important distinction Trump doesn’t talk about. As it turns out, the United States is one of the biggest service producers, which includes finance, telecommunications, engineering, and education. If you account for goods and services, the US trade deficit drops to $566 billion.

While $566 billion is still a big deficit, this omission makes a serious dent in Trump’s case.

Take Canada, for example. Trump’s relationship with Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has notably soured in recent months as the two countries are engaged in a tit-for-tat trade war. Trump claims Canada mistreats American farmers with high agricultural tariffs. Canada does have protectionist trade measures in place for industries like dairy — and overall, the US buys more goods from Canada than it sells. But if you look at the overall trade relationship, the United States actually had an $8.4 billion surplus in trade with Canada in 2017, according to the Office of the US Trade Representative.

Trump doesn’t make this distinction.

He appears to espouse a school of thought that prioritizes a trade of goods over services — and he’s been more than willing to act on it. The administration has imposed tariffs on steel and aluminum and billions of dollars of Chinese goods, and Trump has threatened to escalate tariffs to other industries like foreign cars.

The move has already had repercussions: US trade partners like Canada, Mexico, and China are imposing retaliatory tariffs on products the US sells — like agriculture. Meanwhile, the Trump administration is moving forward with an emergency aid package for farmers who will likely be hurt by the trade war it started.

Sign up for the newsletter The Weeds

Understand how policy impacts people. Delivered Fridays.