clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Conservative activist Ed Whelan apologizes for insinuating a Kavanaugh doppelgänger assaulted Ford

The tweets were deemed a “stunningly irresponsible” defense of Brett Kavanaugh.

Supreme Court nominee Judge Brett Kavanaugh leaves his home September 19, 2018 in Chevy Chase, Maryland.
Win McNamee/Getty Images

On Friday morning, conservative activist Ed Whelan sent the following tweet apologizing for a Thursday evening tweetstorm questioning Christine Blasey Ford’s allegation of sexual assault against Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh, saying, “I made an appalling and inexcusable mistake of judgment.”

But on Thursday evening, Whelan, an attorney and president of the conservative Ethics and Public Policy Center, seemed to truly believe he had found the person who really assaulted Ford in 1982. And it wasn’t Brett Kavanaugh.

Whelan, a prominent figure in conservative political circles in Washington, set Twitter on fire by not only arguing in favor of Supreme Court nominee Kavanaugh’s innocence against Ford’s accusation that he sexually assaulted her, but also accusing someone else of being the culprit — by name, home address, floor plan, and yearbook photo.

Ford herself responded to Whelan’s tweet thread in a statement, saying, “I knew them both,” and added she visited the other classmate in the hospital. “There is zero chance that I would confuse them,” she told the Washington Post.

Whelan has become one of Kavanaugh’s most prominent defenders. He became friends with Kavanaugh when Whelan served as principal deputy in the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel and Kavanaugh was working in the White House counsel’s office during the George W. Bush administration.

On Tuesday, Whelan tweeted a promise: “By one week from today, I expect that Judge Kavanaugh will have been clearly vindicated on this matter. ... There will be no cloud over him.” He added in another tweet: “Senator Feinstein will soon be apologizing to Judge Kavanaugh.”

The tweets caused a stir, particularly among conservatives, and even reached the White House. According to Politico, Whelan was so sure of his ability to prove Kavanaugh’s innocence that he “told at least three associates that his confidence level in his assertions is “close to 100 percent.”

But then came the Twitter thread that Whelan shared on Thursday evening. In short, using a map of homes surrounding the Columbia Country Club (near where both Ford and Kavanaugh attended high school) and floor maps available on the real estate website Zillow, Whelan argued that based on Ford’s statements of what happened that night back in 1982, the perpetrator was likely not Kavanaugh. Instead, he pointed to a classmate of Kavanaugh’s at Georgetown Prep who, in Whelan’s view, looked a lot like Kavanaugh.

In doing so, he shared the address and room layout of the classmate’s childhood home, photographs of the classmate, and the classmate’s full name. I reached out to the classmate — he is not involved in politics and signed a letter in support of Kavanaugh’s nomination in July. I will update if and when he responds. The Washington Post also reached out to the classmate, even visiting his home.

Whelan’s tweetstorm (which he has since deleted) was the rare set of missives that veered so close to defamation it included, at its end, a tweet specifically meant to protect Whelan from charges of defamation by suggesting Whelan was not saying what he was obviously, clearly, saying.

From Ed Whelan’s Twitter feed, September 20, 2018.

“Stunningly irresponsible”

The response to the unsubstantiated assertions was immediate, as journalists and legal observers decried Whelan for committing what some were calling defamation, and many of Whelan’s conservative allies who had been awaiting the information Whelan promised to reveal backed away from his accusation.

A conservative writer told me that though the tweetstorm might not result in legal action, “its legality doesn’t make it proper. A private citizen simply shouldn’t be identified under those circumstances.”

CNN’s Jake Tapper and the New York Times’s Maggie Haberman both deleted tweets sharing the thread and apologized for doing so. Tapper then called Whelan’s tweets “stunningly irresponsible.”

Conservative commentator Ben Shapiro, who had discussed Whelan’s promises of incoming information that would exonerate Kavanaugh on his podcast on Thursday, tweeted that Whelan might “end up in court for defaming a private figure.”

And the Senate Judiciary Committee stayed away from Whelan’s assertions.

Whelan was not alone in making a “mistaken identity” argument regarding Kavanaugh’s accuser. On Monday, Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-UT) said Ford must be “mixed up” and “mistaken” about the identity of the person who allegedly assaulted her.

The Wall Street Journal editorial board made the same assertion on Monday. The Washington Post published a piece on Tuesday by opinion columnist Kathleen Parker arguing a similar line of reasoning, saying, “In a case without evidence, witnesses or corroboration, mistaken identity would provide a welcome resolution to this terrible riddle.”

Hatch’s deputy chief of staff Matt Whitlock even tweeted on Wednesday that observers should “keep an eye on Ed’s tweets the next few days,” and though the tweet was deleted, many speculated that Hatch’s office must have been aware of Whelan’s allegations — speculation Whitlock has since denied.

Sign up for the newsletter Today, Explained

Understand the world with a daily explainer plus the most compelling stories of the day.