clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Obama’s McCain eulogy would be banal under any other president

A celebration of democracy is a criticism of Donald Trump these days.

Barack Obama speaks at John McCain’s memorial service in Washington. Mark Wilson/Getty Images

President Barack Obama eulogized Sen. John McCain on Saturday, setting aside their ideological differences to celebrate the late Arizona senator’s civility, service, and commitment to democratic ideals and institutions.

In pretty much any other moment, it would be heard as a banal speech — a respectful but expected statement from a former president on the life of a longtime senator. It would serve its purpose and remind Americans that we live in a democracy, one based on the principle of peaceful transfer of power. Political rivals are just that, not sworn enemies. They are all part of something much larger than themselves.

It would be boring. But in the age of Trump, it was anything but.

“John cared about the institutions of self-government, our Constitution, our Bill of Rights, rule of law, separation of powers, even the arcane rules and procedures of the Senate,” Obama said, sounding like he was giving a high school civics lesson.

“[McCain] knew that in a nation as big and boisterous and diverse as ours, those institutions, those rules and norms, are what binds us together and give shape to our life. Even when we disagree; especially when we disagree.”

It’s easy to imagine Obama saying similar words about McCain under a President Marco Rubio, Jeb Bush, or Hillary Clinton. McCain and Obama truly do share a commitment to institutional ideals. But the details throughout his remarks get far too specific to obscure whom Obama was talking about.

“So much of our politics, our public life, our public discourse can seem small and mean and petty, trafficking in bombast and insults and phony controversies and manufactured outrage,” Obama said. “It is a politics that pretends to be brave and tough, but in fact is born of fear. John called on us to be bigger and better than that.”

This is the definition of Donald Trump’s politics. He’s a man who once said he prefers soldiers who “don’t get caught,” referencing McCain’s years spent in a POW camp in Vietnam. He’s a man who threw a tantrum inside the White House over whether to call that man a hero in death.

McCain got into it with Trump in return. He even famously voted down Trump’s health care bill in dramatic fashion, which Trump took as a personal affront.

Obama is known for relishing in keeping his cool and for floating above politics. But he didn’t do it Saturday. He juxtaposed the best of McCain against the worst of Trump, without having to speak the sitting president’s name. That Obama would do it — say something about current politics in a moment he could have looked to history — speaks to how dire a situation he views Trump’s presidency as.

Obama highlighted his experience in 2008 running against McCain for president, when racist memes and conspiracy theories flew across the internet and beyond that questioned his place of birth and his commitment to American values.

“It has been mentioned today, and we have seen footage this week, of John pushing back against supporters who challenged my patriotism during the 2008 campaign,” Obama said, referencing a clip of McCain taking the microphone away from a woman questioning Obama’s background at a campaign event in 2008. “I was grateful, but I was not surprised.”

Obama continued: “We never doubted the other man’s sincerity or the other man’s patriotism, or that when all was said and done, we were on the same team.”

Implied is that this does happen — and there’s no question he means Trump.

Trump was a champion of birtherism, reveling in fanning racist attitudes when Obama was in the White House. He kept it up for years. He never apologized, and he even tried to blame Hillary Clinton for his own actions.

Trump went on to rely on these same nativist attitudes and racial fears in 2016 to win over the Republican base. He pitted one group against another, enticing white voters to act on their suspicions of other groups. He made the politics of resentment the central politics of the Republican base.

Obama ended in a final thought on McCain that serves as the perfect rebuttal to Trump.

“That is perhaps how we honor [McCain] best,” Obama said, “by recognizing that there are some things bigger than party or ambition, or money, or fame, or power. That there are some things that are worth risking everything for. Principles that are eternal. Truths that are abiding. At his best, John showed us what that means. For that, we are all deeply in his debt.”

Sign up for the newsletter Today, Explained

Understand the world with a daily explainer plus the most compelling stories of the day.