clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

24 hours in Michael Cohen’s many legal troubles

The chatter that Trump’s personal attorney might flip is getting louder.

Former Trump Lawyer Michael Cohen Returns To Court In New York City Eduardo Munoz Alvarez/Getty Images
Jen Kirby is a senior foreign and national security reporter at Vox, where she covers global instability.

Michael Cohen, President Trump’s longtime personal lawyer and fixer, is battling legal troubles on all fronts.

On Thursday, Cohen asked a California judge to issue a gag order against Stormy Daniels’s attorney, Michael Avenatti. The filing claimed that Avenatti’s frequent media appearances — where he frequently blasts Cohen and Trump — were “depriving” Cohen of “his right to a fair trial.”

A California judge refused to grant an emergency gag order against Avenatti but asked for more information from Cohen’s attorneys and Avenatti in the coming days.

Cohen’s request for Avenatti to cease his “publicity tour” comes as more reports suggest Cohen is thinking about cutting a deal and cooperating with federal prosecutors, and Trump tries to put more distance between himself and Cohen.

Cohen’s gag order request against Stormy Daniels’s attorney

Cohen’s attorneys filed the request Thursday to quiet Avenatti and quash his media blitz. Avenatti’s more than 100 media appearances, and his tweets, are “likely to result in Mr. Cohen being deprived of his right to a fair trial, and threatens to turn what should be a solemn federal court proceeding into a media circus,” Cohen’s attorney Brent Blakely wrote in the court filing.

The court denied the request for immediate relief on Friday but asked more documents from both sides in the case. Avenatti has until June 25 to respond, and Cohen’s attorneys have a final due date of July 2.

Avenatti blasted Cohen’s filing as “complete joke and baseless” on Twitter after Cohen filed the request.

Avenatti is representing porn actress Stormy Daniels, who is suing Trump and Cohen over the 2016 nondisclosure agreement that paid Daniels $130,000 to stay quiet about her alleged 2006 affair with Trump. But that case has been put on hold temporarily as Cohen faces far more serious legal troubles in the form of a federal investigation led out of the Southern District of New York.

Avenatti has also released information about Cohen beyond that case, including documents that revealed Cohen’s firm Essential Consultants LLC had received payments from companies such as AT&T, Novartis, and Columbus Nova, a company tied to Russian oligarch Viktor Vekselberg. These payments were later confirmed by the companies and had reportedly come to the attention of special counsel Robert Mueller.

How close is Cohen to flipping?

The Daniels lawsuit seems the least of Cohen’s legal troubles now. Early this week, reports began percolating that Cohen was thinking of flipping and cooperating with federal prosecutors in the Southern District of New York — though there were conflicting accounts of how close he was to possibly reaching a deal.

New reporting from CNN’s Kara Scannell indicates Cohen has hinted to family and friends that he’s willing to cooperate with federal authorities to “alleviate pressure” on him and his family, and because he’s feeling alienated by Trump, who’s tried to distance himself from his associate.

On Wednesday, George Stephanopoulos of ABC News reported that Cohen’s legal team was departing, signaling Cohen was “likely” going to cooperate with prosecutors. But other reports suggested that while Cohen was shifting legal representation, it might have to do with his lawyer bills. It also wasn’t clear if federal prosecutors had approached him about cooperation.

The federal investigation into Cohen is separate from the special counsel’s investigation into Russian interference, but Cohen’s connections to Trumpworld are diverse and deep. As Vox’s Andrew Prokop writes:

Though Cohen was Trump’s lawyer, his role was far broader than that. For one, he worked as a high-level executive in the Trump Organization, pursuing business deals in the former Soviet Union. For another, he’s a national deputy finance chair of the Republican National Committee. He’s also a wealthy investor in his own right, with extensive taxi medallion holdings and an eyebrow-raising real estate portfolio.

But more broadly, he’s a sort of all-purpose “fix-it guy” who was tasked with making problems for Trump go away — whether that entailed profanely threatening journalists or arranging secret payoffs to hush up sex scandals.

On Friday, prosecutors with the Southern District of New York updated the judge on materials seized in an April 9 FBI raid on Cohen. The court filing revealed investigators had “reconstructed” contents from a shredding machine that added up to about 16 pages, and obtained the contents of 731 messages and call logs from encrypted messaging apps.

Cohen’s lawyers have 10 days to review the materials, according to the court filing.

Trump said Cohen’s not his lawyer but that he’s “always liked Michael”

If Cohen decides to cooperate with federal prosecutors because he thinks Trump is snubbing him, then Trump probably won’t convince him after his comments on Friday.

After sauntering out to the White House lawn to appear on Fox & Friends, Trump answered a few questions from a gaggle of reporters, and when Cohen came up, he said that Cohen was no longer his attorney.

Trump was first asked about Cohen flipping, and he responded that he “did nothing wrong.”

“You have to understand, this stuff would have come out a long time ago,” Trump said. “I did nothing wrong. I don’t do anything wrong.”

“I always liked Michael,” Trump also said, adding that “he hadn’t spoken to Michael in a long time” before saying Cohen wasn’t his lawyer anymore.

“But I always liked Michael,” he repeated.

Sign up for the newsletter Sign up for Vox Recommends

Get curated picks of the best Vox journalism to read, watch, and listen to every week, from our editors.