clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

The new Democratic attack ad against Chris Christie is misleading

Chris Christie is inching closer to a 2016 presidential bid, and Democrats have their arsenal ready: Christie's economic record.

new attack ad from the DNC is in full sarcasm mode, with a voiceover proclaiming, for example, that Christie "turned around" the New Jersey economy — just before a string of clips that let us know about the state's budget shortfall and less-than-impressive job record. Check out the video below:

The Democrats have it right that Christie will have a tough time running on economic numbers — compared to the other governors considering 2016 bids, his state's job creation record is dismal. Of course, that's not something you can blame entirely (or even mostly) on a governor, as other, national-level and geographic factors have such heavy influence on a state's economy.

But the ad also gets a little misleading when they (via a Fox News anchor) claim that Christie presided over a record eight credit downgrades in his home state. It's true that there have been eight downgrades, and according to Bloomberg, it is a record for a New Jersey governor. But here's the tricky part: those downgrades have come from three different ratings agencies, as Politifact has pointed out. If one agency had downgraded New Jersey eight times, that would be a much different, much worse problem for the state.

Standard & Poor's has since 2011 knocked the state down from AA status (meaning the state has a "very strong capacity to meet financial commitments") to A status (meaning it has a "strong capacity to meet financial commitments" but is "somewhat susceptible" to economic weakness), a decline of three notches. That's not great, but a knockdown by eight notches would be truly ugly — a change from AA to BB+, a rating that generally puts a bond just shy of being investment grade, according to S&P, and would probably send the state's borrowing costs soaring even beyond their currently high levels.

The attack ad comes at a busy time for Christie — in addition to giving his state of the state address today, he's also getting in gear for a presidential campaign. He has managed to sign Ray Washburne, the RNC's top fundraiser, onto his team, the Chicago Sun Times reports.

Sign up for the newsletter Today, Explained

Understand the world with a daily explainer plus the most compelling stories of the day.