clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Why the Microsoft-Samsung Patent Dispute Could Be a Big Deal for the Future of Windows Phone

If Samsung and other Android phone makers don't have to pay Microsoft royalties on Android, Windows Phone could become an even tougher sell.

A patent dispute lawsuit Microsoft has just brought against Samsung could have wide-reaching impact on the Windows Phone business.

Microsoft has enjoyed a pretty sweet deal by collecting a royalty, widely believed to be several dollars for every phone that uses Google’s Android operating system. Exactly what patents, and how, is a long and complicated story: suffice it to say that most of the industry has gone along.

This has given Microsoft a steady revenue stream from one of its main rivals in the mobile world. In addition, it has helped Microsoft position Windows Phone as the more economical alternative to Android as Microsoft now gives away Windows Phone to licensees and does not collect a royalty fee on these patents from them. Since device makers have to pay Microsoft for Android, it is no longer free.

But in a legal dispute that came to light last week, Samsung has thrown a wrench in the lucrative arrangement by threatening to stop paying the royalty altogether. To be clear, Samsung didn’t deny Microsoft’s patent claims; rather, it seems to be claiming that Microsoft’s purchase of Nokia somehow invalidates the 2011 deal with Microsoft under which it agreed to pay the patent royalty.

After months of talks went nowhere, Microsoft has filed suit, asking a court to declare its contract with Samsung both valid and enforceable.

If Redmond prevails, Samsung will have to keep paying and will probably owe Microsoft interest on last year’s bill. But should the court find otherwise, Samsung and possibly even other Android makers could be off the hook for those royalties. Au revoir, revenue stream; so long, price advantage for Windows Phone.

And Microsoft needs all the leverage it can muster to convince phone makers to build Windows Phone devices. Thus far, Microsoft has managed to keep most of its current Windows Phone licensees and even added a few more names, but the outcome of this suit could have a lot to say about Windows Phone’s long-term attractiveness as compared to Android.

Judging the merits of the dispute is tough. So far, we only have Microsoft’s side of the story, and even the public version of its lawsuit was heavily redacted.

Samsung, for its part, has yet to comment beyond a statement saying that it “will review the complaint in detail and determine appropriate measures in response.”

This article originally appeared on

Sign up for the newsletter Today, Explained

Understand the world with a daily explainer plus the most compelling stories of the day.