Wearables at MWC: The Good, the Bad, the Ugly

Leading up to Mobile World Congress, wearable technology was shaping up to be one of the big trends of the event, and this certainly proved to be the case. The show saw the debut of numerous smartwatches and fitness bands from the likes of Samsung and Huawei.

Some other big names have wearables in the works this year, but weren’t quite ready to show them, including Motorola and HTC.

Small makers came to Barcelona too, including former Kickstarter projects Pebble and Omate, the latter being a full Android smartphone compressed into a workable — if bulky — wearable.

Here are the wearables highlights from MWC, along with a few of our observations about the devices and their pros and cons.

Samsung Gear 2

Availability and pricing: April, pricing TBD
Compatibility: “Dozens” of Samsung Galaxy devices
What Is It? The Samsung Gear 2 is a smartwatch that can display notifications from your smartphone on your wrist. It also has fitness tracking capabilities with pedometer functions and a built-in heart-rate sensor. Unlike the company’s first smartwatch, the Galaxy Gear, the Gear 2 is based on the Tizen platform, not Android.
The Good: The Gear 2 now has a built-in heart sensor. It is lighter and thinner than the Galaxy Gear and feels better on the wrist. You can also swap the bands with any standard 22mm watch strap. Battery life is now extended from one day to two to three days.
The Bad: Only compatible with Galaxy devices. It’s also still rather bulky.

Samsung Gear 2 Neo

Availability and pricing: April, pricing TBD
Compatibility: “Dozens” of Samsung Galaxy phones
What Is It? The Gear 2 Neo is similar to the Gear 2, but lacks a camera. It’s also made from polycarbonate plastic rather than metal, thus lighter than the Gear 2.
The Good: Though pricing has not been announced, it will be cheaper than the Gear 2.
The Bad: Only compatible with Galaxy devices.

Samsung Gear Fit

Availability and pricing: April, pricing TBD
Compatibility: Samsung Galaxy devices
What Is It? Unlike the Gear 2 watches, the Gear Fit’s primary function is that of a fitness tracker. It includes a heart-rate sensor, pedometer and sleep tracker. The wristband can still display notifications from your phone, but there is no built-in mic for calls or a camera. The Gear Fit runs on a real-time operating system, not Tizen or Android.
The Good: The 1.84-inch Super AMOLED is absolutely gorgeous. The wristband is lightweight and comfortable to wear, and the curved display rests nicely on the wrist.
The Bad: Limited app ecosystem. Only compatible with Galaxy devices.

Huawei TalkBand B1

Availability and pricing: Q2, 99 Euros (around $135 U.S.)
Compatibility: Android (2.3 or higher) and iOS (5.0 or higher) devices
What Is It? The TalkBand B1 is an interesting device, as it combines a fitness tracker with a Bluetooth headset. As a fitness band, it has a 1.4-inch non-touch OLED display and tracks steps taken, calories burned and hours slept. But then you can pop the main piece out of the rubber strap and use it as a Bluetooth headset to take calls.
The Good: The hybrid design helps minimize the number of gadgets you have to carry. The strap has an integrated USB connector for easy charging.
The Bad: The integrated Bluetooth headset design makes it a bit thick up top. The band is also very difficult to put on, and the two-prong fastener doesn’t feel terribly secure.

Sony SmartBand

Availability and pricing: March, 99 Euros (around $135 U.S.)
Compatibility: Android 4.4 devices
What Is It? Aside from tracking the standard fitness measurements and alerting you to phone notifications, the SmartBand was designed to help chronicle your daily life. Using a companion smartphone app called Lifelog, you can press a button on the band to create a “life bookmark” and it will remember where you were, who you were with, photos taken and blips of information from that place and time. All that data is then recorded in the app in a sort of visual journal.
The Good: The SmartBand has a very minimalistic and comfortable design.
The Bad: It lacks any kind of display, so you still have to pull out your smartphone to view your notifications and check your fitness stats.

Even as a new generation of watches hit the shelves, many in the market agree that the industry has yet to find either the killer feature or the proper aesthetics.

This article originally appeared on Recode.net.

We have a request

Vox's journalism is free because we believe that everyone deserves to understand the world that they live in. That kind of knowledge helps create better citizens, neighbors, friends, parents, consumers and stewards of this planet. In short, understanding benefits everyone. You can join in on this mission by making a financial gift to Vox today. Reader support helps keep our work free, for everyone. Will you join us?

One-Time Monthly Annual

$95/year

$120/year

$250/year

$350/year

Other

$

Yes, I'll give $120/year

Yes, I'll give $120/year

We accept credit card, Apple Pay, and Google Pay. You can also contribute via