clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Germany's Top Publisher Bows to Google in News Licensing Row

Axel Springer says restricting Google's use of news snippets caused traffic to plummet.

Reuters / Thomas Peter

Germany’s biggest news publisher, Axel Springer, has scrapped a bid to block Google from running snippets of articles from its newspapers, saying that the experiment had caused traffic to its sites to plunge.

Springer said a two-week-old experiment to restrict access by Google to its news headlines had caused Web traffic to its publications to plunge, leading it to row back and let Google once again showcase Springer news stories in its search results.

Chief Executive Mathias Doepfner said on Wednesday that his company would have “shot ourselves out of the market” if it had continued with its demands for the U.S. firm to pay licensing fees.

Springer, which publishes Europe’s top-selling daily newspaper, Bild, said Google’s grip over online audiences was too great to resist, a double-edged compliment meant to ram home the publisher’s criticism of what it calls Google’s monopoly powers.

Publishers in countries from Germany and France to Spain have pushed to pass new national copyright laws that force Google and other web aggregators to pay licensing fees — dubbed the Google Tax — when it publishes snippets of their news articles.

Under German legislation that came into effect last year, publishers can prohibit search engines and similar services from using their news articles beyond headlines. Last week, Spain’s upper house passed a similar law giving publishers an “inalienable” right to levy such licensing fees on Google.

Seeking to capitalize on the German law, two weeks ago VG Media — a consortium of around 200 German publishers, including Springer — said that Google could no longer publish snippets of text and images from their publications.

Google complied and ran only headlines of articles to limit its liability. It requires publishers who want their content to continue to show up in Google search results to give it explicit permission to do so and freedom from any liability for licensing fees under such laws.

Springer said traffic flowing from clicks on Google search results had fallen by 40 percent and traffic delivered via Google News had plummeted by 80 percent in the past two weeks.

Doepfner said the resulting dramatic drop in traffic to his company’s publications was proof of Google’s overwhelming power in the search market. He said he hoped lawmakers, courts and competition regulators would take action to curb its powers.

“Others will have to pick up the ball now,” the Springer boss told reporters on a conference call following the publication of the Berlin-based company’s quarterly results.

A Google spokesman in Germany praised Springer’s decision.

“The decision shows that Google is making a significant contribution to the economic success of news publishers,” the spokesman said.

He said Google delivers more than half a billion clicks to German news sites per month. The search company has paid more than one billion euros in online advertising fees to German media publishers in the last three years, the spokesman said.

“Google wants to work in the future with publishers on new models to promote their websites and apps to increase traffic and to support digital publishing,” he said.

The German cartel office in August decided not to pursue a complaint against Google by a group of publishers, including Springer, saying that the scope of new legislation was not yet entirely clear.

Google is the target of a European antitrust investigation into the operations of its online search business. The U.S. firm accounts for more than 80 percent of the European Internet search market and more than 90 percent of that in Germany.

The European Union’s new digital commissioner, Guenther Oettinger, said last month that he was mulling a regional Internet copyright levy, taking aim at Google.

Last year, Google agreed to pay 60 million euros ($75 million) into a special fund to help French media develop their presence on the Internet, but search engines will not pay publishers in France for displaying content.

(Reporting by Harro Ten Wolde and Eric Auchard; additional reporting Klaus Lauer in Berlin; editing by Pravin Char.)

This article originally appeared on

Sign up for the newsletter Today, Explained

Understand the world with a daily explainer plus the most compelling stories of the day.